| Login

Marc's Voice

building the open web one bit at a time

Now I hate to say I told you so……

But it looks like Apple took matters into their own hands and extended RSS for podcasting. Their own extensions. On their own.

Danny Ayers caught it - so did Dare Obasanjo.

So this is what happens when we leave things to evolve - on their own. Clearly podcasting was something that needed meta-data - so Apple just went and did it. Their own namespace.

On their own.

What’s wrong with this picture?

Dare puts it perfectly:

This sounds interesting. So now developers of RSS readers that want to consume podcasts have to know how to consume the RSS 2.0 element, Yahoo!’s extensions to RSS and Apple’s extensions to RSS to make sure they cover all the bases. Similarly publishers of podcasts also have to figure out which ones they want to publish as well.

I guess all that’s left is for Real Networks and Microsoft to publish their own extensions to RSS for dealing with providing audio and video metadata in RSS feeds to make it all complete. This definitely complicates my plans for adding podcasting support to RSS Bandit. And I thought the RSS 1.0 vs. RSS 2.0 vs. Atom discussions were exciting. Welcome to the world of syndication.

Finally as Danny says:

So, in summary it’s a bit of a proprietary thing, released as a fait accompli. Ok if you’re targetting for iTunes, for anything else use Yahoo! Media RSS. I wonder where interop went.

I agree with Danny -let’s support Brad Horowitz, David Hall and the Yahoosters on this one. We just need to make mRSS our own and not let it seem like Yahoo owns and controls it.

Can you imagine Flickr APIs for audio and video.

Date: Tuesday, June 28th, 2005 | Time: 8:02 am
Tags:
Add a comment

No Replies

  1. Mark,

    I’ve put together a side by side analysis of the two proposals (Apple’s and Yahoo!’s) on my site (entry is at http://www.tnl.net/blog/entry/RSS_and_Media:_Can‘t_we_all_just_get_along?

    Maybe we can get them all to play on the same team…

    TNL

  2. Mark,

    I’ve put together a side by side analysis of the two proposals (Apple’s and Yahoo!’s) on my site (entry is at http://www.tnl.net/blog/entry/RSS_and_Media:_Can‘t_we_all_just_get_along?

    Maybe we can get them all to play on the same team…

    TNL

  3. Mark,

    I’ve put together a side by side analysis of the two proposals (Apple’s and Yahoo!’s) on my site (entry is at http://www.tnl.net/blog/entry/RSS_and_Media:_Can‘t_we_all_just_get_along?

    Maybe we can get them all to play on the same team…

    TNL

  4. moilfvwgkw ojvbzepby aefnoxchc

  5. moilfvwgkw ojvbzepby aefnoxchc

  6. moilfvwgkw ojvbzepby aefnoxchc

  7. We’re currently shooting the movie’s prequel to explain why all of the living characters are covered in more blood than the zombies in Second Death.

  8. We’re currently shooting the movie’s prequel to explain why all of the living characters are covered in more blood than the zombies in Second Death.

  9. We’re currently shooting the movie’s prequel to explain why all of the living characters are covered in more blood than the zombies in Second Death.

  10. Yikes! I’ll need every secret key I’ve got to jimmy my way out of that one.

  11. Yikes! I’ll need every secret key I’ve got to jimmy my way out of that one.

  12. Yikes! I’ll need every secret key I’ve got to jimmy my way out of that one.

  13. you mentioning the Instead Cup, and was hoping you

  14. you mentioning the Instead Cup, and was hoping you

  15. you mentioning the Instead Cup, and was hoping you

  16. Fear, loathing, and perfunctory seduction

  17. Fear, loathing, and perfunctory seduction

  18. Fear, loathing, and perfunctory seduction

  19. Very Very nice information here… Thanks

  20. Very Very nice information here… Thanks

  21. Very Very nice information here… Thanks

  22. Hey, really nice looking blog.

  23. Hey, really nice looking blog.

  24. Hey, really nice looking blog.

  25. Hello world

  26. Hello world

  27. Hello world

  28. Hello world

  29. Hello world

  30. Hello world

  31. Hello world

  32. Hello world

  33. Hello world

  34. Hello world

  35. Hello world

  36. Hello world

  37. Hello world

  38. Hello world

  39. Hello world

  40. Hello world

  41. Hello world

  42. Hello world

  43. Hello world

  44. Hello world

  45. Hello world

  46. Hello world

  47. Hello world

  48. Hello world

  49. Hello world

  50. Hello world

  51. Hello world